Restoring civic discourse in an age of polarization – with Jim Peyser

 

ADVERTISEMENT

New from CommonWealth Beacon WEYMOUTH MOVES: The spending bill now on Gov. Maura Healey’s desk includes language critical to the overhaul of the former Naval Air Station South Weymouth, which supporters say could unlock thousands of units of new housing plus plenty of space for commercial activity on a site that has been mostly idle for nearly 30 years. Chris Lisinski has the details.  EMISSIONS DODGE: The Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection has no records of state agency vehicle fleet pollution reports and didn’t follow up with the relevant agencies to receive that data, according to court documents connected to a lawsuit the state brought against oil giant Exxon Mobil. Jordan Wolman has more.  NEW MAYOR IN TOWN: Everett mayor-elect Robert Van Campen campaigned on change after his swaggering predecessor, Carlo DeMaria, was marked by scandal this year. But in some ways, Van Campen will keep DeMaria’s legacy alive. Hallie Claflin has more.  OPINION: Now is a critical time to pursue evidence-based policy that fosters both community safety and racial justice, writes Katy Naples-Mitchell, program director of the Program in Criminal Justice Policy and Management at the Harvard Kennedy School’s Malcolm Wiener Center for Social Policy. Massachusetts can take up that mantel with holistic pretrial reform to reduce the use of cash bail and pretrial detention.

Restoring civic discourse in an age of polarization – with Jim Peyser   November 24, 2025 By CommonWealth Beacon Staff

Political debate these days looks more often like trench warfare than reasoned discourse on the pros and cons of important policy proposals. In our age of hyper-polarization, political adversaries are treated more like blood enemies, and issues are often characterized in absolute terms as black-and-white matters of right and wrong, even when they’re often far more complicated than that.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jim Peyser says a healthy, well-functioning democracy depends on us getting out of this cycle of vitriol and restoring a measure of civil discourse to our debates. His day job for all eight years of Charlie Baker’s tenure as governor was secretary of education. But Peyser, whose dad was a congressman from New York in the 1970s and early 1980s – and showed serious bipartisanship by switching parties during that time, from Republican to Democrat – has a deep interest in civic life and in finding ways to bridge some of the divide that has turned political debate into winner-take-all blood sport.

“We're essentially shouting at each other across the divide,” says Peyser, who joined CommonWealth Beacon executive editor Michael Jonas this week on The Codcast. Our positions on issues have been reduced to bumper sticker slogans, he said, “which is essentially crowding out or making it impossible to have an actual conversation around the issues themselves, the problems we're trying to solve, and what some of the solutions might be.”

Over the past year, Peyser has written a dozen issue briefs for CommonWealth Beacon in which he tries to show just what he means – taking on contentious issues facing the state that range from rent control to natural gas pipelines and proposals for a prison construction moratorium. He shows how arguments often come down to balancing trade-offs rather than the moralistic right-or-wrong framing used by those pushing each side most vehemently. (Read Peyser’s concluding essay here, which has links at the end to all 12 issue briefs as well as the two essays he wrote to launch the series that described the polarized state we are in – and how we might begin to chart a course out of it.)

As to whether Donald Trump is the cause or consequence of our poisoned polity, Peyser says “both.”

“He’s an accelerant. But he didn't come from nowhere,” Peyser says, dating the coming apart to at least the 1990s.

Peyser says we are in a more polarized time. But he also agrees with the arguments being made that the center of political gravity nonetheless is in, well, in the center. (A recent New York Times editorial made that case, as does a national report issued last month by a center-left group of Democrats, co-authored by Massachusetts activist Liam Kerr.)

“I do think that the large majority of people are closer to one another than they think,” Peyser says, “and that the extent to which they can't talk to each other or see each other or see the other side as the enemy – it has to do with some assumptions that are made about who's saying what and what underlies their positions as opposed to actual engagement in a particular subject on a particular topic.”

Voters’ view on a particular statement, for example, will be different if they are told it was said by Trump or by Joe Biden, Peyser notes.

As for what it will take to shift the political discourse toward a healthier give and take, “I don’t think there’s a quick fix or silver bullet,” Peyser says. He thinks there are some “structural reforms” that might help. “I am intrigued by the idea of open primaries as a way of limiting the impact of the extremes of either party in terms of driving the candidates that the general election tends to ultimately get to choose from,” he says. (Open primaries are the subject of one of the ballot questions being proposed for the 2026 Massachusetts election.)

“By the same token,” Peyser says, “I think it’s a cultural shift that’s just going to have to happen over time. There's some efforts underway to try to stimulate some of that, some discussions across difference and across party lines. And those are all good. They're all small-scale now and hopefully they'll get bigger and have bigger impact. But I think, in some ways, it's unfortunately hard to see a path through this other than sort of the day-to-day slog of trying to be more reasonable, both in terms of how we talk about issues, but, importantly, how we talk to and relate to one another.”

During the episode, Jonas and Peyser discuss how robust debate can take a turn for the toxic (3:00), the genesis of Peyser’s series on bridging divides (11:30), and how so many voters seemed to hit “burn it down” on both sides of the aisle (23:30).

Listen Now

Job Board Program Officer – Development & Communications – LISC Massachusetts Senior Program Officer/Program Director – The Health Foundation of Central MA Community Engagement & Program Associate – The Health Foundation of Central MA ADVERTISE YOUR JOB LISTING

More from CommonWealth Beacon BREAK TIME: The Legislature has begun its extended holiday break. As they go, Chris Lisinski breaks down what lawmakers sent to the governor’s desk, what measures they can look forward to further debating once they return, and what legislation is stalled.   BALLOT: Voters could be faced with a record-breaking number of decisions at the ballot next year, as 11 different ballot campaigns from rent control to recriminalizing recreational marijuana say they have enough signatures, Chris Lisinski explains.  OPINION: Last week’s annual health costs confab failed to produce any cohesive set of solutions or statewide roadmap on how to tackle the spiraling price tag of health care and the dire financial strains of health facilities, writes Paul Hattis, senior fellow at the Lown Institute.

What We're Reading CLIMATE: New research found that under current global commitments to reduce climate pollution, more than 400 sites with hazardous materials in New England are at risk for a significant flood event by the end of the century. (WBUR)  ECONOMY: Massachusetts research institutions are spinning out companies at a high rate, but experts say the Bay State could take a cue from other states in turning research dollars into startups. The state is falling behind due to licensing bottlenecks, siloed resources, and gaps in entrepreneurial training for researchers. (Boston Business Journal – paywall)  CONGRESS: US Rep. Ayanna Pressley talks about the Epstein files, the end of the government shutdown, and where the Democrats go from here. (GBH News)  EDUCATION: US Education Secretary Linda McMahon said Thursday that the Trump administration was close to finalizing a settlement with Harvard, renewing claims by the White House that Harvard is making progress toward a deal that would resolve a series of ongoing federal investigations. (The Harvard Crimson)  HOUSING: With no limits on rent increase, Berkshires renters confront rising housing costs and leaving apartments they've stayed in for decades. (The Berkshire Eagle – paywall)

Published by MassINC

CommonWealth Beacon, 11 Beacon Street, Suite 500, Boston, MA 02108, United States