Who Gets To Be a Federal Prosecutor?

 



On Wednesday, ProPublica reported that “DOJ has loosened standards” for hiring federal prosecutors. Job listings that once drew highly qualified candidates, who had to compete against hundreds of equally qualified people just for a shot at an interview, are now going to people who have yet to pass the bar.

This has been going on for some time. Back in March, ABC Chicago reported that “In various U.S. attorneys' offices around the country, the federal government is lowering its standards for new prosecutors as it tries to staff up after a talent drain under the Trump administration. In some cases, applicants are not required to have any work experience as a lawyer.”

And what happens when young lawyers, fresh out of school, arrive at U.S. Attorneys’ offices across the country? The layer of experienced career prosecutors, the folks who, regardless of their personal views, understand that prosecution is about the facts and the law, and not the president’s personal revenge agenda, are no longer there to train them. It’s hard to comprehend the magnitude of the crisis that is unfolding at DOJ.

“[A] growing cohort of inexperienced attorneys, many of them fresh out of law school, who are being fast-tracked to fill the shoes of seasoned career prosecutors who fled or were purged from the DOJ in President Donald Trump’s second term,” the ProPublica report explains. With that has come a shift in the docket. Fewer fraud and drug trafficking cases. More immigration. And it’s not as though immigration wasn’t already a major part of federal prosecutors’ caseload before Trump.

One of the most frequently filed charges, across administrations, is the crime of illegal reentry into the United States after being previously deported. It had been the most frequently prosecuted felony immigration crime as well. During Trump’s first year back in office, federal prosecutors filed 63,954 cases in federal district courts, up 11,485 cases, or 21.9%, from fiscal year 2024. The entire rise is attributable to immigration cases. In addition to the illegal reentry charge, which is a felony, prosecutors brought charges for improper entry, a misdemeanor for a first offense, and alien smuggling/harboring. There were also “notable increases” in border-security trespass and customs reporting offenses, which are mostly misdemeanors unless there are repeat offenses. Donald Trump and Todd Blanche’s Justice Department has sacrificed fraud, drug trafficking, and other serious crimes to focus on misdemeanor immigration offenses.

Prosecutors can exert enormous power, and that power is too great to allow the risk it might be abused to go unaddressed. That’s why developing good judgment and prosecutorial discretion in new prosecutors is so critical. But that takes time, both time practicing law before becoming a prosecutor and time working under the guidance of experienced federal prosecutors. People’s lives hang in the balance—if prosecutors can abuse their powers, innocent people can go to prison.

Every new prosecutor is taught the words of former Attorney General and Supreme Court Justice Robert Jackson’s:

“[The prosecutor’s] discretion is tremendous. He can have citizens investigated and, if he is that kind of person, he can have this done to the tune of public statements and veiled or unveiled intimations. … The prosecutor can order arrests, present cases to the grand jury in secret session, and on the basis of his one-sided presentation of the facts, can cause the citizen to be indicted and held for trial. … While the prosecutor at his best is one of the most beneficent forces in our society, when he acts from malice or other base motives, he is one of the worst.”

Who the Trump administration is hiring may seem like the least of our worries right now, but it could be a remarkable problem for the long haul.

When I was hired as a prosecutor, six years out of law school with litigation experience in Big Law in Washington, D.C., and at one of Alabama’s biggest firms, a federal judge who mentored me, Judge Clarence Allgood, cautioned me that the job wasn’t about statistics. It wasn’t about doing more cases than the person in the office next to me. He encouraged me to never forget that investigations were about real people, with families and lives to live. As a Supreme Court decision put it: Prosecutors could strike hard blows, but they had to be fair ones. Or, as my criminal chief, Bud Henry, put it, “no one case matters more than the integrity of this office.” Bud lived by those words, insisting that we always protect defendants’ rights while prosecuting our cases. We were expected to get convictions the right way. Had anyone suggested we do a case to make the president or any other powerful person happy, he would have shown them the door.

I’ve never forgotten Bud’s advice, or the help I received from other experienced prosecutors. My colleagues shared the wisdom prosecutors pass on from one generation to the next. That can only happen when you hire prosecutors with enough experience to understand what they don’t know. It can only happen when experienced lawyers are there to teach the newcomers. It can only happen when the Justice Department values judgment, independence, and integrity as much as it values winning cases. Once lost, institutional knowledge and integrity aren’t easy to rebuild. The consequences when it is lost aren’t just statistics. They’ll be measured in unfairness and injustice, in people’s lives and freedom.

That’s what makes this story important. The damage being done to the Justice Department isn’t just the cases being brought—or not being brought—today. It’s the changes being worked on the institution itself. DOJ is hardly the only place where that’s happening. Across the federal government, decisions that receive little public attention today will shape what our democracy looks like long after this administration is gone. We need to know what they are, why they matter, and what it will take to undo the damage.

There are no shortcuts to repairing our democracy. The next two years will require sustained attention to laws, institutions, and democratic principles that determine whether our government works for the American people as the Founding Fathers intended. We can’t fix what we don’t understand.

That’s why I hope you’ll become a paid subscriber and support my work. I want to continue putting my 25 years of experience as a federal prosecutor, including eight as a U.S. attorney, to work for us during this critical period. We need to understand what happened yesterday and recognize the developments that will matter tomorrow. Subscribers support the time, independence, and careful analysis this work requires, and help keep Civil Discourse available to everyone who wants to learn, regardless of their ability to pay. If we do this right, we can build something more enduring out of our daily conversations: a community equipped to understand their government and insist that it live up to its obligations. If you’ve been thinking about becoming a paid subscriber, I hope you’ll decide to do it right now.

We’re in this together,

Joyce

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

CONGRESSMAN JAKE AUCHINCLOSS

Revelations

One last thing.....